Lovechild 17: A Fairytale Romance
“Once in a while, right in the middle of an ordinary life, love knocks our doors, enters our lives, & changes it forever. You start believing in dreams, you start making wishes & you start to trust your heart even more! That love holds your hands & makes you feel you are safer than ever; that love makes you believe that nothing can go wrong now; and oh that warm hug, which makes you want to spend your entire life then & there!"
Anamika Mishra, VoiceMates - A Novel
You know the kind of love, right? When the Prince sees Cinderella for the first time.... When the Prince finds Sleeping Beauty and wakes her with a kiss... When the Prince meets Snow White and... You get the picture.
Well, believe it or not, that's pretty well the kind of love my parents had. Although their meeting was a little different and no members of the royal family were involved.
Some time in late 1936 or early 1937, Robert’s younger sister, Jean Shaw, started to date a young man named Jim MacDonald.
Jim's parents and youngest siblings lived in Rossburn, Manitoba, a village about 24 km north of Kelloe, the village where Robert had lived with his mother after Jennie sold the farm. Jim's father was a barber and also owned the town pool hall. Robert was about a year and a half older than Jim, and Jean was four months younger, so it's quite possible they'd met at least casually.
I don't know if Jean was visiting family in the Rossburn area when they met, or if Jim was working in Brandon at the time. But in any case, the two began to date, and things became quite serious. I'm pretty sure that Jean's mother, Jennie, and some of her older brothers and sisters wouldn't have been happy about this.
Pool halls weren't exactly the best place to hang out in those days. They were often filled with smoke, encouraged gambling, and allowed alcohol. And Jim's dad not only owned the pool hall, but the family lived above it. The fact that he was also a barber might have helped, but not much.
Plus, while they considered themselves Presbyterian, Jim's parents weren't even remotely as committed to the church or Christianity itself as the Shaw family, especially Jennie and her late husband.
In the end, Jean broke it off, mainly because of Jim’s drinking. While her brothers might have a drink now and then, Jim went further. When she asked him to stop drinking, or at least slow down, he seemed unwilling or perhaps unable to do so. In the end, after a few months, she moved on.
Almost immediately, she met someone else. And on November 27, 1937, she married Howard Maltby, a 28-year-old from New Brunswick who was working as a salesman.
Sounds like the end of the story? No, it hasn't started yet.
No one ever told me exactly how it happened, but during the time Jim and Jean were dating, Jim introduced Jean to his sister, Margaret MacDonald, and the two women became friends. Early in April of 1938, Jean introduced her brother, Robert, to Margaret. I'm guessing that Margaret visited Jean in Brandon at the house she and Howard were living in after their marriage and Jean invited Robert to come over. But it's possible that Jean, Howard, and Robert went to Winnipeg for some reason.
Robert was eleven months younger than Margaret, who had been living in Winnipeg and working for Eaton's since she was 16 (almost 12 years). When they met, Margaret had been engaged for seven years to a man named "Tommy." (If I ever heard his last name, I've forgotten it). Tommy's wife was Catholic and although they were separated, she refused to give him a divorce.
A few weeks after Margaret met Robert, she broke off her engagement to Tommy.
Was it love at first sight? Did Robert look like a prince? Did Margaret look like a princess? No idea. Maybe they were the Depression-era version of a prince and princess.
Robert and Margaret had a few things in common.
- Both came from working class families who had immigrated from the British Isles.
- Both had fathers who lived great distances from their families.
- Neither they nor their parents had finished high school.
- Both liked to dress as well as up-to-date as they could afford.
But they also had a lot of differences!
- Margaret was the eldest of seven while Robert was the second youngest of 12.
- Margaret's small family had moved a number of times as her dad tried to find better work, and they rarely saw their relatives. Robert had lived in one area all his life, with many family members on his mother's side as well as older brothers and sisters. In fact, some of his best friends were his nephews.
- Margaret left home at 16 to live in Winnipeg and get a job as a sales clerk. Robert had worked for his family and was now working as a butcher, but he was still living with his mother.
- Margaret was an extrovert who loved being around other people, and always wanted to be up on what was happening. Robert was a quiet introvert who was a slow reader and had difficulty writing.
They do say opposites attract!
In Margaret, Robert no doubt saw a very attractive, independent, big city girl who dressed in the latest fashions, played tennis, danced, and enjoyed life. She was probably unlike anyone he'd met before.
In Robert, Margaret would have seen a tall, dark, handsome man who dressed as well as he could afford to and was the strong, silent type who would look after her.
Added to that, I think they recognized the same longing in each other. Both had had some hard knocks, but kept going. And they both wanted what others had―a family, a home, and a future that was better than the past. Together, they might make it.
So on Sunday, May 15, 1938, just six week after they first met, Robert and Margaret were married in Brandon, Manitoba, where Robert lived.
Margaret saved the clipping from the newspaper.
Shaw - MacDonald
The marriage of Olive Margaret, daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Bruce MacDonald, of Rossburn, and Robert Alexander Shaw, youngest son of Mrs. George B. Shaw, was solemnized in the manse of First United Church on Sunday afternoon, Rev. F. E. H. James officiating. Fourteen were present to witness the ceremony.
The bride was given in marriage by her father and wore a pretty wedding dress of white satin with a wreath of orange blossoms in her hair. The attendants were Mr. and Mrs. Howard Maltby, the latter wearing a frock of pink taffeta with matching accessories. During the signing of the register, Mrs. Albert Roney sang “In the Garden,” the accompanist being W. Johnson.
Following the ceremony, a wedding dinner was served in the home of the groom’s sister, Mrs. Roney. The guests present were Mr. and Mrs. Bruce MacDonald, Fay, Terry and Mervin MacDonald, and W. Johnson, all of Rossburn, Mrs. G. B. Shaw, Mr. and Mrs. Maltby, Mr. and Mrs. Roney, and Miss Lillian Lovatt, of Brandon. Mr. and Mrs. Shaw will reside in the city.
I have no idea whose wedding dress Margaret wore. Unless it was an impulse buy, I assume someone gave or loaned it to her. It definitely isn't something she'd normally have chosen, and I know she didn't like it (especially the wreath in her hair). She never showed anyone the wedding picture.
I find it surprising that Margaret's aunts Maudie and Ettie weren't at the wedding. She'd been boarding with Maudie and Mac for nine years, and was close to Ettie and Bert, too. Her brothers Jim and Hughie weren't there either. Nor was her sister, Brucie. I don't know if they accidentally missed Brucie in the write-up or if she couldn't come for some reason. She'd only have been nine, while Terry was five and Faye three. Margaret's dad never had enough money to buy a car and never learned to drive, so unless her brother Mervin had a car (he'd have been 22), they'd likely have come by train.
Most of Robert sisters and brothers didn't live that far away, but none of them came. In fact, Walter lived right in Brandon, and he and his wife aren't mentioned!
But this was 1938, and the Depression was at its peak, so it might have simply been a lack of money as well as the short notice. Plus, even fourteen people would have been very crowded in the dining room of the Shaw/Roney house where they all went for the wedding dinner.
That house was about to become Margaret's home, too.
For Margaret, the most lasting memory from her wedding, a story she told me many times over the years, concerned her father.
After the ceremony was over, when the guests were getting ready to leave, her dad told her how embarrassed he was that he’d been unable to buy her a wedding present. He apologized several times, and then said he’d give her all the money he had.
He then reached into his pocket, pulled out a quarter, and handed it to her. At the time, a quarter was the price of a haircut.
Each time Mom told me that story, her eyes filled with tears.
She remembered him as a laughing, cheerful man who was always joking, but it must have been very difficult for him, especially during the depression. He worked long hours as a barber as well as running the pool-hall, yet was barely able to provide more than the basics for his family.
Can You Relate?
I don’t know about you, but my mind kind of boggles at the idea of marrying someone you've known for just six weeks. However, marry they did, and despite massive differences between their backgrounds, personalities, and interests, as well as struggles with things beyond their control, they stayed together for more than 50 years.
Do you have any "Fairytale" stories in your family's history?
LoveChild: Life Lessons from an Ugly Duckling is the story of my struggle to adjust to the life I was given, and my eventual discovery that, not only had I become a swan but, contrary to my perceptions, I had always been one. Though I didn't realize it until many years later, my life was part of a much bigger plan that all made perfect sense.
I'll be blogging my story once a week.
Find links to all these blogs at:
Have my new posts sent directly to your inbox.